• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
Denver Medical Study Group

Denver Medical Study Group

Leading through Learning----Healthcare Innovation and Reform

  • Home
  • About Us
    • About DMSG—-HISTORY
    • Testimonies From Our DMSG Community
    • DMSG Guidelines
    • DMSG Advisory Board
  • Events
    • Upcoming DMSG Events
      • 25th of January, Dana Jacoby, CEO, Vector Medical Group
    • Past Events Library
      • 7th of December, Scott Becker Founder and Publisher of Becker’s Healthcare and Becker’s Hospital Review
      • 2nd of November, Laura D. Rosenthal, DNP, ACNP, FAANP, President of Colorado Nurses Association
      • 29th of September, Robert K. Smoldt, Chief Administrative Officer Emeritus, Mayo Clinic Associate Director, Healthcare Delivery and Policy Program, Arizona State University
      • 25th of August, Glenn Robinson, FACHE/President, Pacer Consultants, LLC
      • 28th of July, Gary Salman, CEO, Black Talon Security, LLC
    • Event Recaps
      • Event Recap–Gary Herschman, Attorney, March 21st
    • Events Calendar
  • DMSG Healthcare Podcast
  • DMSG Sponsors
    • Partner With Us
      • Anchor Health Properties, Platinum Sponsor
        • Podcast With Ben Ochs, CEO & Managing Partner with Anchor Health Properties
      • COPIC, Platinum Sponsor
        • COPIC’S COMMITMENT & SUPPORT TO ADDRESS COVID-19
      • C.U. Denver Business School MBA-Health Administration, Platinum Sponsor
        • Hospital President reflects on his deep CU Denver connections
        • Podcast with Rulon Stacey, Director of Graduate Programs at UC Denver
      • Eide Bailly, LLC., Platinum Sponsor
        • Independent Physician Practices: Sell, Consolidate, or Stay Put?
        • Eide Bailly, LLC, Blog
      • Ent Credit Union, Platinum Sponsor
        • Ent Regular Financial Checkup During a Crisis
      • Metro State University-Denver, MHA -Healthcare Administration, Platinum Sponsor
      • MGMA, Platinum Sponsor
      • Project C.U.R.E., Platinum Sponsor
      • University of Denver, Platinum Sponsor
        • I don’t feel well. What do I do now?
        • University of Denver Blog
        • Digital Health – Perfectly Positioned Across Populations
      • Vector Medical Group, LLC, Platinum Sponsor
        • Industry Brief and Q&A with Dana Jacoby, President/CEO, Vector Medical Group, LLC; Q1 2022
        • Podcast With Dana Jacoby, Vector Medical Group & Gary Herschman, Epstein Becker & Green
        • Podcast with Dana Jacoby, CEO with Vector Medical Group
        • Industry Brief and Q&A with Dana Jacoby, President/CEO, Vector Medical Group, LLC; Q4 2021
        • Q & A with Dana Jacoby, President/CEO, Vector Medical Group, LLC
  • Healthcare News
    • Healthcare News Both Locally and Nationally
    • Healthcare News When We Hear it!
  • DMSG Student Interns
    • DMSG Student Intern Blogs
  • Blogs
    • Chris Hadley, Founder, Denver Medical Study Group
    • The Bridge–Cortese, MD & Smoldt, MBA Blog
    • Dr. David Pate’s Blog
    • Colorado Health Institute
  • Contact

“How, Not When” by Denis Cortese, MD and Bob Smoldt, MBA

July 25, 2020 by Chris Hadley

The Bridge

Across the healthcare delivery chasm, from where we are, to where we want

About:

Denis A. Cortese, MD, joined Arizona State University (ASU) in 2010 as Foundation Professor, Director of ASU’s Healthcare Delivery and Policy Program, and President of the non-profit Healthcare Transformation Institute based in Phoenix, AZ. He is an Emeritus President and CEO of the Mayo Clinic, and former head of the Mayo Health Policy Center.

Robert K. Smoldt, MBA is Chief Administrative Officer Emeritus of the Mayo Clinic and currently serves as Associate Director of Arizona State University’s Healthcare Delivery and Policy Program. He served as a member of the Mayo Clinic Board of Trustees and Mayo Clinic Executive Committee from 1990 through 2007. Mr Smoldt served two terms on the Board of Catholic Health Initiatives and continues as a member of its Finance Committee.

 

How, not when Blog

July 21, 2020 hcblog

As new Covid 19 cases have spiked recently in states like Texas and Florida, it is not unusual to hear that the main reason for the spikes is that these states started opening their economies too soon. However, that claim ignores the fact that there are other states that started opening their economies at the same or even earlier time, and so far have accomplished gradual reopening while maintaining decent Covid experiences. Since there are legitimate public health issues from runaway Covid infections, non-Covid patients not getting the care they need, and also from forcing more and more people onto unemployment and poverty, it seems to us that rather than just wringing our hands over “states who started reopening too soon,” it would be more useful to see what might have allowed some states to start reopening successfully – thus better addressing the above public health issues.

Of the thirteen “rabbit” states that started reopening their economies early, we will look at four. Two have received much national publicity recently because new confirmed Covid cases and hospitalizations have increased significantly – Texas and Florida. Two have received hardly any national publicity, because they have been progressing relatively well with the pandemic – Indiana and Colorado. To us, it is very important to analyze what Indiana and Colorado have done. We should learn from our successes, as well as our failures.

All four states imposed a “Stay at Home” order by early April – IN on March 23; CO on March 25; FL on April 1; TX on April 2. By early May all four were starting to reopen their economies – CO on April 27; TX on April 30; IN on May 4; FL on May 4.

We will focus on each state’s experience with new hospital admissions by day since their start of reopening. Because TX does not report new daily hospitalizations, but rather daily Covid hospital census, we are using the data from Texas Medical Center in Houston as a proxy – the Houston metro area accounts for >25% of all Covid hospitalizations in Texas and its daily hospitalization census trends parallel that of the state as a whole. We (and others, including the governor of Colorado) put a greater emphasis on hospital admissions, rather than cases, because case numbers can be skewed by the number of tests being conducted.

Public health experts watch hospitalizations closely because it can indicate how severe an outbreak is in an area. It’s considered a better measure than new cases because it’s not as reliant on the availability of testing.

Moreover, since PCR tests can detect live, dead or even fragments of the virus, there isn’t a clear correlation between a positive PCR test and clinical disease presentation or progression.

Colorado was the earliest to start reopening on April 27. While newly confirmed cases were still on the rise at the time the reopening was announced (April 20th), new Covid hospital admissions had already dropped significantly. Peak confirmed Covid cases happened on April 23 (just 4 days before reopening) at 969, while Covid hospital admissions had peaked two weeks before reopening, on April 14 at 282. By the first of July, new daily hospital admissions dropped to 30.

Daily new Covid-19 hospitalizations and 7-day rolling average for the state of Colorado

Indiana, the other state that seems to have kept covid-19 under control, began re-opening on May 4th, and with a similar trajectory in hospitalizations as Colorado. Peak Covid hospital admissions occurred on March 31 at 181 and dropped to 38 by July 1, 2020.

Daily new Covid-19 hospitalizations and 7-day rolling average for the state of Indiana

As for the two states that have seen a recent major surge in both cases and hospitalizations (Florida and Texas), it is of interest to note that in both locations, new daily hospitalizations were essentially flat prior to re-opening and for about a month following the initial re-opening date.

Daily new Covid-19 hospitalizations and 7-day rolling average for the state of Florida
Daily new Covid-19 hospitalizations and 7-day rolling average for Texas Medical Center in Houston, TX

In our view, a major reason for the success in Colorado and Indiana is that each has made a serious effort to actually follow the four needed elements to control this virus. What are the four elements?  They were well pointed out in an article by Dr. Atul Gawande in a May article on reopening.  He comments on how his medical center had been doing it for its own employees. It is well stated in his own words,

The Boston area has been a covid-19 hotspot. Yet the staff members of my hospital system here, Mass General Brigham, have been at work throughout the pandemic. We have seventy-five thousand employees—more people than in seventy-five per cent of U.S. counties. In April, two-thirds of us were working on site. Yet we’ve had few workplace transmissions. …in the face of enormous risks, American hospitals have learned how to avoid becoming sites of spread. …These lessons point toward an approach that we might think of as a combination therapy—like a drug cocktail. Its elements are all familiar: hygiene measures, screening, distancing, and masks. Each has flaws. Skip one, and the treatment won’t work. But, when taken together, and taken seriously, they shut down the virus.

To us, a key phrase in this quote is “when taken together, and taken seriously.” Both Colorado and Indiana have stressed repeatedly to wash hands, test, socially distance, and use face coverings/ masks.  In our view, Florida and Texas were both much more cavalier in their implementation of reopening – especially with regard to social distancing and face coverings/ masks.

While it remains to be seen if Colorado and Indiana can maintain their success with keeping Covid in check, the two states have shown us that, it is possible to start reopening the economy and not have a Covid resurgence take over the efforts. While many claim that reopening the economy was the mistake of Florida and Texas, in our view it was not the reopening itself, but how it was carried out. We need to get our economy going again to help reduce the upcoming public health issues that are and will be coming from limiting healthcare access for non-Covid patients, as well as our massive unemployment and expansion of poverty – both of which will also increase social disparities of health. Let’s get our economy going again, but do so in steps and in keeping with what has been shown to work in some of our states.

Post navigation

← Lessons from covid19 – Part 3: Where are we now? What’s next?

 

Share this:

  • LinkedIn
  • Email
  • Print
  • Facebook
  • More
  • Twitter

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sidebar

For Media Inquiries & Sponsorship Opportunities contact:

Chris Hadley, Founder
834 S. Perry St., #F-423
Castle Rock, CO 80104
303-249-5572
chris@denvermedicalstudygroup.com

Sign Up Here to Get Event Announcements in Your Inbox

* indicates required

Contact Us

For Media Inquiries & Sponsorship Opportunities Contact:

Chris Hadley, Founder
834 S. Perry St., #F-423
Castle Rock, CO 80104
303-249-5572
chris@denvermedicalstudygroup.com

Newsletter

Keep up with our news and events.

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2023 · Denver Medical Study Group · All Rights Reserved ·